How to Practice a New Piano Piece
When the right hand carries the melody and other notes at the same time, this is how I learn a new piano piece, in short parts. First only the melody, until it is in your system. Then the right hand again with all the notes. Then the left hand with the pedal. And only then the hands together.
A student played for me in my Live Coaching last March, a piece I couldn't find at first. While we waited for the score, I said it's better always to send me the PDF before the lesson: "It's easier and we are better prepared." Then the student said: "I have played it perfectly, hands separated. But the problem is hands together. And most of all, bar 16 is the most difficult one."
So we went through bar 16, chord by chord, note by note. At one point I said: "You have to read the notes one by one. And I don't know now where you are." For a moment I had lost my place myself. Some notes in the right hand were wrong, and then it came: Oh, I always played it wrong.
You should read first the notes, I said. It's the easy part. It's a matter of understanding which line each note belongs to, for this you must look carefully.
Then the student asked for a suggestion: How to play it more lively, and more beautiful? My answer was about the order you learn it in.
That order starts after the first read, where you find out where the real work in a piece is. I wrote about that in my post on a plan from the first read.
Learn the Melody First
I would first search for the melodic line. Play the melody without the extra notes, so that you firstly have that in your system. And you're feeling the melodic line, so that you know how to phrase it, to make the music go forward.
In the lesson I put the first step like this: "So the first step is to start to begin with the right hand, only the melody. And then, if it is well trained, then with the right hand again, but with all the notes."
To play the melody without the extra notes, you have to know which notes belong to it, so this step needs the careful reading too. If reading is still slow for you, read them one by one, as I asked in bar 16.
This is the order I gave for a right hand that has the melody together with other voices.
Once you know the melody this well, you may want it to sing more. That is a subject of its own, in my post on a melody that sings.
All the Notes, in Short Parts
Then the right hand again, with all the notes. In that step I ask for:
- "you work also on the other voices"
- "try to play it musical"
- "that you get a sense of where it goes"
The length I give is small: "Try first to practice in little shorter parts, one, two or three measures, to make them fluent." Melody first, then all the notes, inside each of those parts.
In those short parts it is already music. As I said in the lesson: "After you make preparatory exercises and you know the notes, I immediately start to implement the music. I'm going to search for the sound and for the music. Even though it is slower still and in small parts, but still music."
Each short part goes through every step before you go to the next one. In that piece the first two bars were such a part. I asked first to figure out the coordination, where you have to go, and then: "Play this with the pedal, please."
Short parts are close to what I call working in divisions, in my post on learning a piece in small divisions without mistakes. There, too, you read the notes first and play hands separately before the hands go together. With a melody in the right hand, I split the work of that hand in two and start with only its melody.
The Left Hand With the Pedal
"And then you play the left hand with the pedal. And at the same time you're trying to search for the sound." So the pedal comes in already here, with the left hand alone, before the hands go together.
Why separately? "Working on the different layers separately makes the music clearer." In this order, the melody is one layer, the other notes in the right hand are another, and the left hand with the pedal is one more.
Practising Hands Separately, Then Together
In bar 16 the trouble showed up with the hands together, but the wrong notes were already in the right hand alone. Three of the four steps are hands separately. Only the last one is together.
In my Super Fingers course, about doing the exercises hands separately, I say: "It's not to become like the school child has to follow the rules. But it has the reason that you feel much better when you do the hands separate."
The last step: "And only then you try to play the things together." Then: "See, and then a few times. And then you have it in your system, okay."
And after that: "Okay, and then you're going to work with it until you have it."
Try this
Take one phrase of a piece you are learning.
- Play only the melody of the right hand, until it is well trained.
- Play the right hand again with all the notes. Try to play it musical.
- Play the left hand with the pedal, and search for the sound.
- Only then play together, a few times, and try to get it in tempo.
Then you go to the next part.
In short
In short parts, give the melody its own time first, alone, until you know how to phrase it. Then add one layer at a time: all the notes, then the left hand with the pedal. Put the hands together last, a few times.
Where It Shows Up
With all the correct notes, the music still doesn't go forward when the melodic line isn't in your system yet.
Decide which piece you learn next, and play me its melody in live coaching, alone, before the other notes come in.









